THE LILIES

Four queer teenagers are stuck in an infinite time loop that taps into their collective worst moment.

The question of what really happened to Charlotte Vanderheyden at the Lilies Society’s Founder’s Night initiation lies at the heart of this convoluted mystery, which is told from the perspectives of four Archwell Academy seniors: Rory Archwell, Blythe Harris, Veró Martín, and Drew Simmons. A lockdown drill finds the four teenagers trapped together in a closet and caught in a time loop that forces them to relive the initiation over and over again, even though neither Drew nor Veró are Lilies. Further complicating matters, each one is holding on to secrets of their own. Rory and Blythe, legacy students and former lovers, played key roles at the initiation. Charlotte and Drew (who uses they/them pronouns) were roommates. Veró is an activist who creates radical disruption under the persona of Malcriada, and her most recent artwork portrays Chancellor Archwell (yes, Rory’s mother) as a TERF. The frostiness among the racially diverse group thaws as they band together and discover that they share a common—and disturbing—history. The more they reveal, the closer they get to discovering what really happened to Charlotte—and maybe even other initiates. While the story’s underlying premise importantly confronts generational trauma and repeating patterns, and the explorations of race, queerness, and exclusion are thoughtful, the novel struggles with the tenuous portrayal of time looping.

A complex story sidelined by a confusingly executed paranormal element.